Thursday, 22 August 2013

The Indefinable Definition of Feminism

feminism► noun [mass noun] the advocacy of women's rights on the ground of equality of the sexes.
-ORIGIN late 19th cent.: from French féminisme.
feminist► noun a person who supports feminism
►adjective relating to or supporting feminism
-ORIGIN late 19th cent.: from French féministe, from Latin femina 'woman'.
It's odd the shock that the declaration 'I'm a feminist', or 'I advocate feminism' can elicit. I doubt if I was to declare that I was a socialist, an anarchist, a tory, that it would provoke such questions. There seems to be a weird fascination, a certain taboo that surrounds the term. In general terms, people are unable to see beyond stereotypes when it comes to feminists. On numerous times I've been asked when I'm going to 'become a lesbian' and when I'm going to 'cut all my hair off'. Most of the time, I find such responses funny, if not predictable. People are scared of the unknown, and for many, feminism is just that - it holds a certain sense of antiquity, as if it's been relegated to the past and is now irrelevant. Feminism, for so many is such an alien, ungraspable concept that when they meet someone who openly declares themselves a feminist, they want to solidify what it actually means to be a feminist and what that actually entails. They seem to crave a definitive version of what feminism actually is; or realise its instability which will enable them to successfully discount it.
I'm wary of such definitions. Feminism isn't something solid and wholly definable. It is an unstable term, but for me that is one of its merits. Undoubtedly there are certain aims of feminism which are common to all of its strands, but equally it is subjective. What feminism means for one woman will mean something wholly different to another woman. Which is why it is impossible to impose an over-arching, hegemonic discourse upon feminism. But also why such questions and such a need for a definition is unsettling.
Someone once asked me how I could possibly dare to call myself a feminist and still strive for a breakdown of gender stereotypes. After all, inherent in the word 'feminism', is the idea of a segregation of gender, an innate difference between men and women and as a result it is self-defeatist and self destructive - what it strives to undermine it, through its very name, serves to reinforce. At the time I was speechless and absolutely furious; I saw the sense in the argument and as a result briefly saw the possible limitations of 'feminism' as both an ideology and a movement. What resulted was an ideological crisis. Sure, I know that feminism has nothing to do with creating a world where women are superior to men. I knew that feminism does not have one blind, all consuming, and furious purpose. I knew that it is possessed of hundreds and hundreds of different strands and facets. I also knew that his argument against feminism was limited and reductive, but I couldn't say exactly why. I could not articulate a solid and impenetrable argument as to why he was wrong.
Laughably it's taken me several months to realise what I should have said to him there and then. The origins of the feminist movement were to ensure equality between men and women, yes, and to bring to an end thousands of years of male dominance and female oppression. Obviously it had the interests of women at its very core. But feminism has changed; just as all movements and ideologies do, it has progressed and expanded and in a way mutated. Women's rights will always be at the heart of the feminist movement yes, but more importantly it is human rights which are at its core. For me feminism's aim is to see the destruction of a patriarchal system which does not just imprison women but all of humanity. Men are not the culprits here- patriarchy is, and men are just as entrapped by patriarchy as women are, just as the Wall Street Banker is as much entrapped by capitalism as the anti-capitalist activist. We are not rallying against individual people, individual genders, individual classes; we are rallying against a dominant belief system - one which has all of humanity by the throat.
To truly understand feminism, one has to look beyond the label. It's true that if you are thinking in terms of semantics, then yes, 'feminism' is a somewhat reductive and oxymoronic term. But that in itself is a reductive attitude, and you yourself are guilty of imposing those limitations. If you are to think in such imprisoning modes of thought, you may as well throw up your hands and surrender to the world we live in. There is nothing progressive about such a declaration. Linguistically, feminism is tied to women, but symbolically, it goes far, far beyond that. Words are signifiers, but what is signified can be wholly different.
Language is in itself phallocentric and, as a result, a tool of patriarchy. It is part of a Symbolic Order which forces us to view the world in terms of binaries (day/night, man/ woman, culture/nature, love/ hate) and as a result, artificially creates divides and a hierarchical mode of seeing. If you chose to think of 'feminism' in terms of its Oxford University Dictionary definition, then you chose to view the world in terms of such binaries. Such restricted thought results in the conviction that feminism must be part of a binary, it must have an enemy, an opposite and naturally there must be a group who are marginalised and excluded from it. This causes people to flatten and compress feminism into a narrow, aggressive ideology which is solely reserved for women, is purely concerned with women, is filled with hostility towards men, is tied to an elitist attitude and, as a result, lacks transcendentalism.
But it is possible to reclaim language and to see beyond definitions which are tied to and inextricable from patriarchy and its resulting binaries Ultimately, this will result in us having taken certain steps to rid ourselves of the 'ideology of domination'. Feminism does not signify a belief system that is tied to the feminine alone, instead it is expansive and wide-ranging awash with ideas of freedom and liberty and equality. Feminism is an unstable term and in this instance, this instability is positive. There is not one totalitarian definition of feminism, instead it encompasses innumerable strands and nuances. Do not think of it in terms of a binary, because such thinking is dangerous. Instead it is part of a dialectic and an all-encompassing fight against oppression.
'Feminism is not simply a struggle to end male chauvinism or a movement to ensure that women have equal rights with men; it is a commitment to eradicating the ideology of domination that permeates Western society on various levels- sex, race, class to name a few- and a commitment to reorganizing... society so that the self-development of people can take precedence over imperialism, economic expansion and material desires' - bell hooks
The photo is of a caricature of a woman cleaning the house, posted using the creative commons license from thisgeekredes.

Thursday, 2 February 2012

'Take Me Out': A Celebration of 'Compulsory Hetereosexuality' and Prescribed Gender Roles

The other day, I was unlucky enough  to be exposed to the horrorshow of ITV's 'Take Me Out', a show hideous even in its very format. I was actually in total shock that something so outmoded, so tacky and so utterly, utterly tasteless could be aired on prime time TV on a Saturday night. Its basic premise is that each week thirty women feature on the show and each week, three of those thirty women are picked by three men to go on a date. If the women remain unpicked, they remain on the show for the duration of the series, waiting for a man to single them out and offer them validation. If you too have witnessed the absolute horror of this show, you will know exactly what I'm talking about. For those of you that haven't, YouTube it, and see what comes up... it's awash with misogyny, sexism and gender stereotypes and is utterly deserving of the cliche of a 'meat market'. The women are  treated as chattel, possessions and are awarded no autonomy. Instead what the viewer is faced with is thirty 'princesses' waiting for their 'Prince Charming'. Sure, the argument is there that these women are allowed a small amount of sovereignty. After all, if they 'no likey [said man in question, they are able to show their distaste through], no lighty'. But this superficial autonomy is sure enough wrested from them; their ultimate fate, whether or not they are 'lucky' enough to be deemed suitable date material, rests in the hands of the male.

What I found most disconcerting about this show, is that there will most certainly be an army of young girls and young boys out there, idly internalising the show's concepts when it comes to dating, love and gender. What this show is reproducing is a highly tasteless fairytale, albeit disguised by diamante and fake tan. For the girls, it is a matter of looking pretty, simpering sweetly, and saying whatever it takes to win 'Prince Charming' over. Or, depending on which half of the angel/ whore dichotomy they have chosen to embrace, smiling seductively and suggestively at the man in question, and generally trying to exude an aura of the 'femme fatale'. And for the boys, it's simply teaching them that girls are easy pickings- swagger arrogantly enough, embrace a hyper-masculine role enough, and all the girls will fall at your feet and wish to be wooed.

What's more, it embodies a highly insidious myth. The whole concept of the show is built upon the notion that women and men should and need to be part of heterosexual relationship in order to lead a fulfilled life, and therefore upholds the notion of women as the 'inverse', the 'other' of men.  It is simply a celebration of prescribed gender norms. Indeed, the ultimate, deciding question put to two girls was: 'What signature dish would you cook to win over "Tom's" heart?' I can't remember the actual name of the male contestant in question, but that is highly irrelevant. What's important is the stereotypes that this question is raising and reinforcing- it categorically enforces a domestic role upon the female contestants, reducing them to a one dimensional version of femininity- the 'feminine mystique'. The women themselves seemed eager to endorse this received notion- excitedly, almost manically, declaring  what culinary delight they'd whip up. In short they did not seek to reject or overturn this stereotype, they simply and unquestioningly, upheld it. Surely, this can only lead to countless young girls, sitting in front of the television on a Saturday night, swallowing the belief that in order to have a satisfactorily heterosexual relationship, they have to embrace a standardised version of femininity and a sufficiently domestic role.It saddened me that this was the ultimate question - a question which is mired in stagnant and outmoded gender roles. It, and the show itself, do not represent or celebrate anything remotely progressive or expansive. Instead, the show simply applauds the discourse of heteronormativity, and directs another generation towards prescribed gender roles and 'compulsory heterosexuality'.

Monday, 31 October 2011

Running, street harassment, agency and silencing...

I frequently go running. Running for me is a form of release; it makes me feel empowered, it makes me feel strong and able-bodied. But recently I've noticed something troubling and rage inducing whilst out jogging.

Street harassment is something which as a woman I have come to expect. Don't get me wrong- I don't like it and I definitely don't accept it as an unchanging part of society. I expect it, nevertheless. For some reason though, the street harassment that I encounter when I am running enrages me far more than when I am just, say, walking to the bus stop. This outlook is by no means correct, after all, street harassment is street harassment, no matter what the victim is doing at the time. But for some reason, running for me is somehow more sacred. It's my time, and as I said, it makes me feel empowered and able. In away, it can be also trance-inducing; when I run I forget about almost everything else, so god forbid that a man should try and desecrate it with some lewd and misogynistic remark. But worryingly, I have noticed that more and more I am encountering cat calls and wolf whistles when out on my daily run. The other day, three boys, still in their school uniform, so no more than 15 or 16 shouted, 'Oi oi sexy!' at me as I made my way around Peckham Rye. Another encounter involved three teenage boys on bikes hurling lewd quasi-sexual noises in my direction. Another day, I was again making my way around Peckham Rye, when a man, possibly in his mid-twenties, said 'Mmmmm. Move that sexy body' in an incredibly sinister and actually quite disconcerting way.

There are numerous other occasions but it would be ridiculous to mention them all here. I'm pretty sure that most of you know already the kind of ridicule and misogyny that women encounter in the street. The point of this post isn't to simply regale you with tales of  street harassment, but more to question why men feel compelled to deride and taunt women in such ways. What puzzles me the most, is that I encounter it when I am running. It seems ridiculous that I should be prey to such taunts when I am exercising. This is for several reasons. I by no means subscribe to blame culture, in fact I despise it and actively seek to destroy it. I know that what you are wearing, how you are behaving is no reason for a man to attack you verbally or physically. But I want to make a point: when I go running, I by no means conform to any ridiculous beauty ideal or rigid stereotype of femininity which society is consistently exposed to in the media. In short, I do not look like the expected and supposed object of male desire or fantasy. In fact, I look a little ridiculous. I wear lycra leggings, a baggy t-shirt, my hair is scraped back into a ponytail and I definitely do not wear any make-up. So what is it that compels men to shout disgusting sexual propositions and lewd remarks?

At first, I was inclined to think that by not wearing make-up, that by going out and not giving a shit, by not conforming to a narrow version of what makes a woman an object of sexual desire, I was somehow making myself appear vulnerable to these men. In other words, an easy target. Robbed of a supposedly protective mask of make-up, was I in a way laying myself bare? In refusing to take on the standard trappings of an object of male desire, was I somehow laying myself open? Incidentally, once when running in Cardiff, I fell over and cut my hands on the gravel path. Falling over really, really hurt and I cried, possibly more from shock than anything. But I wanted to get home as quickly as possible, so I picked myself  up and ran home, still crying, and with two bleeding hands. Even then -- even when I had tears streaming down my face, and blood pouring from my hands, I still encountered the catcalls of three European men outside a hostel. They were shouting something unintelligible, but there was no doubt as to what it concerned. I may not have been able to understand what they were saying, but their tone and their gestures were unmistakable. So in some ways, it would appear to be exactly what I suspected:  when men sense a certain vulnerability, they react to it. Still, I think it goes much deeper than that. It relates to a form of control, a form of oppression.




I think that for some men, running, or in fact any physical activity, or in fact any female activity at all, represents some sort of challenge. After all, running is not a sign of passivity, of helplessness. Instead, it signifies strength. When a woman takes part in a physical activity they are not lying prone, doll-like and passive, instead they are claiming agency -- agency of movement, agency of their own limbs, agency of their mind and of their consciousness. In short, the image of a woman running is at odds with the eternally passive, eternally motionless woman we see in advertisements, pornography, lad's magazines, hell, even fairy tales and countless other outlets of both high and low culture.


These images are wholly at odds with the image of the female runner; she is endowed with a strength, a mobility, an agency that the women of these images have been robbed of. She is surely a symbol of the ability that we have to transcend static constructions of femininity and break free from the imprisoning modes of thought that advertising, pornography and many other aspects of popular culture actively encourage. I may be over thinking this, but the reaction of much more than just a handful of men when I am out running would suggest otherwise. Through their derogatory and lewd remarks, they are seeking to objectify me, to force me back into the narrow and restricting cage of femininity that society has conditioned them to accept as the norm. Furthermore, they are trying to force me to reclaim that stillness, that passivity, that silence, whilst attempting to reclaim some skewed form of macho sexual power. For them a woman who appears to have agency is threat to their own masculinity.

Indeed, I was in utter shock this weekend, when I stumbled across this blog: http://hotchicksofoccupywallstreet.tumblr.com/. Yes, that's right... 'Hot Chicks of Occupy Wall Street', 'The Sexy Side of Protesting Corruption'. I was astounded by it. The women featured in this blog are doing something amazing. They are protesting against corporate greed and capitalism; they're taking part in a movement that has the ability to totally revolutionise and change society. Indeed, the Occupy protests across the globe are, for me, imbued with a sense of transcendence. People, not only women, are claiming agency and actively seeking change. The writer of this blog, however, appears to want to nip this in the bud and return women to a state of passivity, silence and objectification. Of course, he does this through objectifying and sexualising this handful of 'hot chicks'. As a result they are silenced and stripped of any agency which they may have achieved. For me, what is the most ironic thing about this blog, is that the writer is clearly in support of Occupy Wall Street and therefore, presumably all for the destabilisation of the status quo. Did it fail to cross his mind that capitalism and patriarchy are wholly intertwined? And that through reinforcing this particular strand of the prevelent ideology, he's actually supporting what he seeks to undermine. It seems ridiculous to me that, in trying to celebrate a  protest against oppression and and an imprisoning ideology, all he has served to do is reinforce an even more oppressive system of beliefs. He has silenced these women, through objectifying them, and as a result is colluding with the system. The voiceless and the marginalised are, after all, far easier to control.

I'm not quite sure how I got from writing about the agency of running to decrying an ignorant blogger, but it definitely illustrates how pervasive and insidious the objectification of women is: someone who obviously considers himself to be revolutionary is guilty of doing what patriarchy has always striven to do. If a revolution is to actually take place, then everyone needs to be free from oppression. This blog is a sad indication that this is not the case. Until women are able to claim agency and not be silenced, no one will ever be truly free.